“I can barely conceive of a type of beauty in which there is now Melancholy” —Charles Baudelaire
Melancholy is the new wine and cocktail lounge in the Post District in downtown Salt Lake City. While most everything in the district is new construction, Melancholy is located in one of the original buildings on site. At 150 years old, the space was originally a storage annex for American Barrel and later a post office. Now, walking up to it, the exterior looks like a modern sleek bar. Open the doors, and a surprise awaits: Black walls, white marble, a big plate glass window and touches of brass all mix together with vintage finds. It’s as if a Gothic library had a love child with an eccentric botanist lab with a little dark academia apothecary thrown in for good measure. Every single piece of decor was hand-selected by the dynamic team of Shaleen Bishop and Fallan Keyser.
“We found most of the stuff for Melancholy secondhand and at vintage stores,” Fallan explains. “We wanted to use things that needed to be refurbished a bit. We had things reupholstered.” There are old paintings, mirrors on the walls and even post office boxes at the front of the downstairs bar.
“The upstairs bar back and the post holding up the edge of the bar downstairs is repurposed from an old headboard,” says Shaleen, giving another example. “We addded a lot with the stories from the old pieces that we brought in. It feels like it adds to the story and the history of the building.” Not bad for a space that started out as cinderblock, graffiti and peeling plaster.
As co-owners, Shaleen and Fallan bring a deep background to Melancholy. Fallan previously owned Good Grammar, and together, with Shaleen ran the Secret SLC immersive events. While Secret SLC didn’t survive through COVID, the great partnership did. Shaleen texted Fallan, saying, “I missed doing cool stuff together.” Fallan agreed. Three weeks later, they walked into Melancholy for the first time and knew just what they wanted to do.
So, why Melancholy? “We started playing with names,” Shaleen says, “and we just kept coming back to that word. The way it’s often used is focuses on the sorrow part of melancholy. But if you really look at the definition, it’s not necessarily sorrowful. It has a lot to do with nostalgia and memories, so we wanted to bring that to the bar.” The goal at Melancholy is to have an intimate, quiet bar and a gathering spot for the community.
Intimate is accurate. There are only a few seats around the downstairs bar, while the upstairs has table tops with seating. It feels like the type of place to go, read a book over a glass of wine solo or for an intimate tet-a-tet over cocktails. Both owners are now in their 40s. “We a space where we would want to go and people our age would want to spend time,” says Shaleen.

Not only is Melancholy woman-owned, but the entire leadership team is made up of women. Sommelier Natalie Hamilton, Bar Manager Morgan Michel and Social Media Manager Jillian Herman round out the team.
Natalie and Morgan have worked together hand in hand to create a curated, constantly rotating wine experience and unique wine-centric cocktails. The wine list constantly rotating. They will bring in a case or three of a specific wine; when it is gone, it is gone.
“Natalie brings in wines from different areas because we didn’t want to proclaim that we were an Italian or French wine bar,” says Fallan.
As the Bar Manager, Morgan pulls together the cocktail menu, incorporating some sort of wine feature as a crossover. While the cocktail menu also rotates seasonally, sherry, vermouth and sake make their way into the concoctions. Morgan even makes a syrup in-house with the herbs and spices that make the flavor of cola. In a nod to non-drinkers, a specialty 0% ABV beverage menu is as curated as the wine list. “I think a lot of times people that don’t drink alcohol don’t feel comfortable in bars,” Shaleen notes. “And we want everyone to feel comfortable and on equal footing here.”
Melancholy has no kitchen, so food is limited to bar snacks. But the bar snacks are really good. Torres potato chips, tinned fish and marinated olives all grace the menu. You can also bring food in from other restaurants.
To continue to build a community at Melancholy, they host a monthly book club called “Books Take Flight” and other events, like an oyster pop-up with wine and oyster pairings. On Sunday, they set out a bunch of classic games. On Monday, there is an industry night. The seating capacity will almost double with a new patio opening in the summer.
When You Go…
Melancholy Wine & Cocktail Lounge
556 S. Gale Street, SLC
melancholyslc.com | @melancholyslc
See more stories like this and all of our Food and Drink coverage. And while you’re here, why not subscribe and get six annual issues of Salt Lake magazine’s curated guide to the best life in Utah?